Saturday, March 14, 2009

The Concerns of "Harry and Louise" circa 1994

YouTube Link to videos here.

Because my daughter is working on her undergraduate thesis on comparing the health care reform policy environment in 1994 and now, we were looking at the old Harry and Louise videos.

It is funny, because there are two issues raised in the commercials. In the first, set "Sometime in the Future,"the concern is about having to choose among "insurance plans designed by government bureaucrats" and the lack of choice among doctors, hospitals, etc., should this happen. And the cute little line about, "Remember our old plan? That was a good one."

Well, of course, those ships have all sailed. Our insurers now dictate our provider choices ever more restrictively. If you've ever changed your insurer, you probably have come to terms with looking through the provider book and figuring out which PCP practice to switch to, whether to go "out-of-network" to keep your old specialists, and whether to drive to a new hospital in your network. Unless, of course, you are in a federal plan, designed by bureaucrats, which generally will provide you with substantially more choice than your private plan.

It's also worth saying that in most markets, insurance consolidation has resulted in ever dwindling choice in private insurers. So, the choice thing? Not so much.

The second commercial talks about the dangers of "community rating" to the premiums of the younger and healthier. This is exactly right, and Uwe Reinhardt has been warning about this lately. If not forced to buy insurance, those who are at lower risk of needing health insurance will opt out, driving up the premiums for those buying insurance, particularly small employers who can't spread the risk out. A genuinely fair concern that is still in the mix of issues that need to be dealt with today.

So, how to deal with it? Everyone must be in. We must accept the societal bargain that when we are healthy, we subsidize those who are not. When our kids are healthy, we subsidize our neighbors' kids with diabetes and autism and cancer. When our parents have chronic illnesses, we spread the risk amongst us all.

Sphere: Related Content

No comments: